I will start this post by telling you that during this MTV event
it was raining and cold and I have a small umbrella and everyone makes fun of
it because it’s so small and it does this... a lot!
For the first MTV event we had written consent to take photos of anyone in attendance, as they knew ahead of time the nature of what we were doing and why. While we set up on the edge of town, where a large number of immigrants resided, I started taking photos of the surrounding area. The hillside we were on was covered in trash and animal remains. Sheep, goats, farmers and children passed by dumping their trash on the ground without a second thought.
After taking photos of the area I moved right into taking
photos of the event. However, I did not remember to ask my boss if we had consent ahead of time to take pictures of the
participants. That was a mistake. Normally, I’m very good at checking with
people first before taking photos of them, their merchandise or anything else
they might own. I blame the cold rainy
day and my eagerness to capture some shots before a total downpour that
caused the mental gap (and I know that this is a sad ass excuse).
Quickly someone noticed that I had taken their picture and
started to get angry. He did not come towards
me but instead at one of our immigrant coordinators, demand that I stop taking
photos. I was then called over to show
the photo I took and give confirmation that I deleted the photo he was in. I then promised not to take photos of him
anymore.
My boss reassured me that I could take photos of people,
just not their faces. So I kept my
camera out and took photos of the MTV and the back of heads. Regardless, I saw how the men reacted to me
every time I came near or lifted the camera up.
Some of them even started to leave before getting a HIV test. It was then that the immigrant coordinator
explained to me that some of the people we were reaching out to are here
illegally. They were afraid that if
photos were taken of their face, they would be at risk for deportation. I felt horrible. The fact that my actions could have caused
someone to leave without receiving a HIV test and valuable information made me feel completely counter
productive to the cause.
My boss and the immigrant coordinator had differing opinions
about whether I should continue to take photos of the MTV event. My boss wanted photos of the event for her reports and to show the diversity of OPALS events. The coordinator wanted people to feel safe with a organization they were unfamiliar with. This put me in a difficult position, but it
was up to me and I agreed with the coordinator and put my camera away. By that time though, I already had the
reputation of “the girl with the camera” and no one wanted to talk to me about
what we were doing. I was only useful
that day to the participants who spoke English.
While there were only a few of them, it was nice to be able to speak
confidently about what OPALS was doing.
Between the rain, cold and camera issues I was feeling
pretty useless and miserable. However, I did learn a
lot about the people I’m working with and maybe what to expect in the future at the
MTV.
And I got a new umbrella.
Tomorrow is our final
day for the MTV blog posts where I fight The Man! Sort of…
That jawbone could be from either. Sheep and goats have the same facial bone structure. :)
ReplyDelete